top of page

Your Email Click Rate Might Be Lying to You

4 days ago
5 min read

On a coaching call in late September, a client and I were going through the results of her latest email campaign, and she wondered whether her email click rate was falling short. She had been exploring the comparisons in her Constant Contact dashboard, and one of them made her clicks look low next to an average. When I pulled up the report, her click rate was 1.3%, which was higher than her own average for recent campaigns and above the 0.95% industry average her dashboard showed. The bigger point came next. Her campaigns are built to start conversations, so they ask readers to reply, and the only links lead to her website and her services. I told her I wasn't terribly concerned about the click rate either way, because clicking was never the main thing that campaign asked anyone to do. She also told me that one of the people who did click ended up on the phone with her, which was a lovely reminder that a small number of clicks can still turn into a real conversation.


If you send email campaigns of your own, you might have one in your report that looks the same way. The numbers in your email platform are tidy and easy to compare, which makes them tempting to use as a report card for every campaign you send. The catch is that each metric measures one specific behavior, and not every campaign is asking for that behavior.


Woman at a bright desk reviewing an email campaign report on her laptop, with a notebook and yellow mug

Check what your email click rate is being compared to

Dashboards often show several comparisons at once, such as your own recent campaigns, your industry, and sometimes a broader average, and they don't all tell the same story. My client's dashboard showed a 0.95% industry average for her, while MailerLite's data from December 2024 to November 2025 put the overall average across its senders at 2.09%, so benchmarks can differ widely by source. Constant Contact calculates click-through rate as unique clicks divided by sends minus bounces, so each person counts once no matter how many times they click. Before you decide a campaign fell short, confirm which comparison you are looking at and whether it fits your type of business, and treat any benchmark as a rough guide.


Name the job the campaign was built to do

Before you judge any number, name the job that campaign was built to do. Most email campaigns fall into one of four jobs, and each one has its own scoreboard.


  • Get a click. A campaign featuring a blog post, an event page, or a booking link. Click rate is your scoreboard here.

  • Get a reply. A check-in, a question, or a "what are you working on this season?" note. Your scoreboard is your inbox, because replies never show up in the click column.

  • Get a registration or a booking. Clicks are only the first step. The number that counts lives on your registration page or in your calendar.

  • Stay familiar. A warm update that keeps you on someone's radar. Judge it over several months by watching list growth and unsubscribes, rather than by any single campaign.


None of these jobs is better than another. A service-based business usually needs all four over the course of a year, and the trouble starts only when one scoreboard gets used to grade every campaign. Open rates deserve a careful look too. Apple's Mail Privacy Protection has made them less dependable, and Twilio's September 2025 guide recommends treating clicks as the main engagement signal because clicks are intentional, which helps explain why a low click rate can feel so alarming.

Example tracker pairing each email campaign with its goal, where to look, and the result

If the job was a click and clicks came in low, look inside the email

When the goal was a click and the clicks were lower than you hoped, I start with the body of the campaign. There is a lot to look at in there, and most of it is easy to adjust:


  • How many links the campaign has, and whether each one earns its place

  • Where the main link sits, and whether a reader sees it without scrolling

  • Whether the call to action stands out or blends into the text

  • How long the campaign is

  • How it looks on a phone


Link count deserves a closer look, because the research doesn't give one simple answer. MailerLite's analysis of more than 317,000 campaigns, published in February 2026, found that emails with 2 to 5 links had the highest click rate, about 19.5% above single-link emails, although single-link emails brought in more orders per click. That data comes from accounts selling products, so it may not mirror a service-based business. Constant Contact advises centering each email on one primary goal and removing links that don't support it, while noting that focused doesn't mean only one link. Link count is worth testing, one change at a time, rather than following a rule. Constant Contact also suggests placing a prominent button or link near the top, repeating the main link in a second spot, and sharing the highlight in the email while letting your website cover the details, all of which are quick to try.


Count the replies yourself

Replies land in your regular inbox, so your platform's report can't see them, and a campaign that brought in a handful of heartfelt responses can still show a lackluster click rate. For a service-based business, those replies are often the whole point, since a reply is a conversation that has already started. A simple tally does the trick: the date, the campaign, and the number of replies, kept in a note or spreadsheet right next to your report. It takes about two minutes, and it gives you a second scoreboard that matches the job.


Put the goal at the top of the report

Here is the habit that makes the rest of this easy. Before you send a campaign, write one line in your content calendar: "Goal: replies," or "Goal: clicks to the event page." When the report arrives, read each campaign against its own goal instead of against a single average. You end up making changes based on what the campaign was trying to do, which beats reacting to a number that was never measuring it.


Quote graphic: Check the goal first, then read the number

A lower click rate isn't always a red flag. Sometimes it means the campaign did a different job, and the report simply wasn't built to show you that. Check the goal first, then decide what to change.


If you'd like help building an email rhythm where every campaign has a clear job, I would love to chat. You can book a free discovery call with me here.


Related Reading


Sources



Tracey Lee Davis is the founder of ZingPop Social Media and an email marketing manager and social media coach for women in service-based businesses. A Constant Contact Certified Partner since 2015, she helps small business owners feel confident, capable, and seen online. zingpopsocial.com

Comments


bottom of page